Yeah. IMO there are many many fallacys when it comes to EFI.
Some of the more common ones are "start maps" and "maps for passing X"(as in smog checks asf).
I´ve been doing this for a rather long time and to this day i have no idea what that is.
I don´t get it and what´s more i don´t get peoples reasoning as far as that goes? I mean...the engine will tell what it is able to deliver. From any aspect in my book and you can´t very well ask it to do something the hardparts within wasn´t designed to.?
*shakes head*
If one of the criterias for instance is to reach a 100ppm HC pollutant and you do that,why would you want to strive AWAY from that as you´re done?
Or...take the implimentation and intelligent use of IAC motors. That can certainly be used to calm a "jumpy" engine down as long as we´re talking plenum setup,and as such affect idle and light load pollutants too.
Sorry to say very very few invest the time needed to grasp a basic understanding of these matters,and they DO ad up!!!
Yeah.
VR trigger setups/issues can be hard to solve. As always just cause there´s more to it than meets the eye.
A few yrs back we spent considerable time trying to see some sort of pattern in this,and to this day the best "answer" we can come up with is to keep the POS VR as occupied as you can.
Amongst other setups we fooled around with a VEMS unit on an old cossie merc. When we moved the trigger WIRE like half a foot in either direction where it ran along the passenger side inner fender we started to see interferance over the scope-with the eventual trigger error down the line.
The truth of the matter is that a VR sensor is nothing but one big ass microphone and as such will catch up on anything it can and pay that forward,and then it is the ECUs job to sort out what IS a trigger pulse and what´s not.Residual thresholds be damned kind of....
Hard at its best to say the least,and the lesson learned is that the OEM boys that play around with this style of work are no fools. The VRs impedance and type is a deliberate choice and so is the routing of the trigger wire 100 times out of 100.
Hence...why you SHOULD be able to get away with a "motronic setup" if so equipped stock. Someone has done most of the jo already...
Other than that.... Hall effects.
Yes.
You are correct in that the Hall effects GT101 will work just the opposite of a VR in as much that it frowns on to many trigger events per cycle. We´ve run em with success to 18 teeth,but it is also imperative within reason how much ferrite passes the sensor. That aside though...install in and forget it,and i don´t know about you guys but i for one have got better things to do than to try n sort VR trigger errors out.
That much for "main" triggers. When it comes to home signal triggers via the cams or control of the VANOS or whatever....Hall 100 out of 100.
Another common "fault" is that the general installer misjudge the importance of the physical stability of the trigger,and it often gets worse when these people are to handle a two or three trigger setup.
I´ve seen trigger wheels made out of sheetmetal stock in radial that basicaly expanded the living daylights out of the trigger sensor...and of course the installer stood there looking like a rabbit caught by the highbeams.
Hell...i´ve seen people been handed the advice of need of shielding the VR wire-to combat EFI and RMI-and what they did was to run into moms kitchen to steal the aluminium foil that the wrapped around the sensor wire..
U could say....that´s one way of doing it,however it isn´t the CORRECT way..
I was recently involved in a 2001 Reynard super oval indycar where the owners thought it would be a good idea to pick up the electrics needed as far as wires,fuse holders n such from the local NAPA dealer. Weeeeeeeeeeell....
Let´s just say that i welded the Inconel 625 hedders up and abandoned the project....cause you don´t put together a 250mph car at like 200 000 dollars and cheap out on stuff like that. EFI in that case btw was a DTA S80...
I guess what i´m saying is that there is no magic. Just application of common sense,hard work and time...a job that deserves to be done deserves to be done RIGHT.